In an 18-year-study on attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
(AD/HD), Mayo Clinic researchers found that treatment with prescription
stimulants is associated with improved long-term academic success of
children with AD/HD. The Mayo Clinic results are the first
population-based data to show stimulant drug therapy helps improve
long-term school outcomes.
A related Mayo Clinic study reveals that compared to children
without AD/HD, children with AD/HD are at risk for poor long-term
school outcomes such as low achievement in reading, absenteeism,
repeating a grade, and dropping out of school. Both studies appear in
the current edition of the Journal of Development & Behavioral
Pediatrics.
Nearly 2 million children, or approximately 3 percent to 5 percent
of young children in the United States, have AD/HD. This disorder
affects a child's ability to focus, concentrate and control impulsive
behavior (http://www.nimh.nih.gov/publicat/adhd.cfm). This disorder is so common that most school classrooms have at least one child with clinically-diagnosed AD/HD.
"In this study, treatment with stimulant medication during childhood
was associated with more favorable long-term school outcomes," explains
William Barbaresi, M.D., Mayo Clinic pediatrician and lead author of
the reports.
Significance of the Mayo Clinic Studies
The two Mayo Clinic studies are the first population-based,
long-term studies to investigate links between AD/HD, school
performance and factors that modify long-term school performance of
children with AD/HD. Researchers followed the children from the time
they were born for, on average, 18 years. Of the more than 5,000
children evaluated, 370 (277 boys and 93 girls) were identified as
having AD/HD. Researchers matched them by age and gender to 740
children who did not meet the research criteria for having AD/HD. In
addition to medical stimulants such as methylphenidate, also called
Ritalin, the study examined the effects on school outcomes of maternal
age, socioeconomic background, and special education services the
students received.
School Outcome Results At a Glance
The children treated with stimulants typically began taking
medication in elementary school and received it for nearly three years
-- on average, for 30.4 months. Results indicate:
Gender: Girls and boys with untreated AD/HD were equally vulnerable
to poor school outcomes -- and girls may be at risk for being
under-identified as having AD/HD, and therefore undertreated.
Reading: By age 13, on average, stimulant dose was modestly correlated with improved reading achievement scores.
Absenteeism: Both treatment with stimulants and longer duration of medication were associated with decreased absenteeism.
Grade Retention: Children with AD/HD who were treated with
stimulants were 1.8 times less likely to be retained a grade than
children with AD/HD who were not treated.
Implications for Parents and Caregivers
Dr. Barbaresi believes that both studies provide the first solid
evidence of the long-term negative academic performance associated with
untreated AD/HD -- as well as evidence for the best way to manage this
problem. Dr. Barbaresi says, "The finding that treatment with stimulant
medications is associated with long-term improvement in school outcomes
is significant. Previously, there was evidence that treatment with
stimulant medications improved short-term academic performance, but
there was no good evidence that long-term outcomes are better with
stimulant treatment. Our data can guide clinicians in their efforts to
help children with AD/HD succeed in school."
About the Studies
The Mayo Clinic team had a unique ability to identify groups of
children with and without AD/HD. Mayo Clinic has maintained a
comprehensive communitywide medical records database since 1935, and
researchers had access to all conditions, diagnoses and treatments the
children received. In addition, Mayo obtained a research agreement with
Independent School District #535, Rochester, Minn., including public
and private schools, to access non-identifiable school records of all
children born in Rochester between Jan. 1, 1976 and Dec. 31, 1982. This
enabled researchers to correlate school performance of both children
with and without AD/HD in terms of medical conditions, maternal age,
socioeconomic status and special education efforts.